Imagine a year after BYU was shut out of the NFL Draft, two former Cougars are poised to hear their names called—but will their combine performances seal the deal? This is where the rubber meets the road for Chase Roberts and Jack Kelly, who stepped into the spotlight at the NFL Scouting Combine in Indianapolis this week. But here's where it gets controversial: while both players showed promise, analysts are split on whether their skills translate to NFL success. Let’s dive into their performances, careers, and what the experts are saying—and this is the part most people miss: their college legacies might just be the X-factor.
Chase Roberts: The Route-Running Technician
Roberts, a four-year starter for BYU, turned heads with his consistency and route-running prowess. At the combine, he clocked a 4.64-second 40-yard dash (34th among wide receivers), a 37-inch vertical jump (15th), and a 10-foot-6-inch broad jump (16th). His 10-yard split of 1.6 seconds (30th) showcased his initial burst, but it’s his technique that stands out. NFL analyst Lance Zierlein notes, ‘He runs routes with good disguise and above-average technique,’ though he questions Roberts’ ability to separate on deep throws. But here’s the kicker: Is being a ‘technician’ enough in a league that craves speed and explosiveness?
During his BYU career, Roberts racked up 170 receptions for 2,586 yards and 18 touchdowns, earning All Big-12 Third Team honors in 2025. As a team captain, he consistently delivered, surpassing 800 receiving yards in his final two seasons. Yet, his age (an older prospect) could impact his draft slotting. Do you think Roberts’ college dominance will outweigh concerns about his NFL readiness? Let us know in the comments.
Jack Kelly: The Aggressive Playmaker
Kelly, a linebacker with a knack for disruption, impressed with his athleticism at the combine. His 4.57-second 40-yard dash (eighth among linebackers), 37-inch vertical jump (11th), and 10-foot-5-inch broad jump (seventh) highlight his explosiveness. He tied for first in the 20-yard shuttle (4.19 seconds), proving his lateral quickness. However, Zierlein points out, ‘His struggles to find leverage as a run defender pop up too often on tape.’ But here’s the twist: Could his special teams potential be his ticket to the NFL?
At BYU, Kelly was a force, recording 105 tackles, 15 sacks, and four forced fumbles in just two seasons. As a senior, he became the first Cougar in a decade to post 10 sacks in a season, earning First Team All-Big-12 honors. Across his five-year college career (including time at Weber State), he amassed 185 tackles, 28 sacks, and nine forced fumbles. Is Kelly’s aggression a double-edged sword, or will it make him a Day 2 steal? Share your thoughts below.
The Bigger Picture
Both Roberts and Kelly have the resumes to intrigue NFL teams, but their combine performances have sparked debate. Roberts’ route-running vs. his lack of elite speed, Kelly’s athleticism vs. his run defense inconsistencies—these are the questions teams are grappling with. And this is the part most people miss: In a draft where every detail matters, their college legacies could be the tiebreakers.
As we await draft night, one thing’s clear: BYU’s drought might finally be over. But will Roberts and Kelly live up to the hype? Only time will tell. What’s your take? Are these two Cougars ready for the NFL spotlight, or is there still work to be done? Let the debate begin!
